It’s Complicated
The mac and cheese lied to me
It was a Wednesday. Long day, nothing left in the tank, didn’t want to think about what to cook. So I made the mac and cheese — the real one, the one with three kinds of cheese and a full stick of butter and breadcrumbs on top.
It was perfect at 9 PM. Warm, heavy, every bite a small vacation from the day. I ate two bowls. I felt held.
By 10:30 I felt like I’d swallowed a brick. By Thursday morning the fog was back — that heavy, sluggish, don’t-talk-to-me feeling where your body is technically awake but hasn’t fully committed to the idea.
The mac and cheese told me exactly what I wanted to hear the night before. And then it ghosted me by morning.
That’s the relationship most of us have with comfort food. It’s not love. It’s a situationship.
Why we reach for it
It’s not weakness. It’s chemistry.
When you’re stressed or exhausted, your brain wants the fastest path to calm. The combination of high starch and high fat creates a neurological shortcut — it triggers dopamine and opioid release, which effectively mutes the stress signal. Your body feels relief. Your shoulders drop. The day gets quieter.
But the calm isn’t real. What’s actually happening is an insulin spike so steep that your parasympathetic nervous system kicks in and forces a slowdown. It’s not peace. It’s a crash dressed up as comfort.
The food industry knows this. That’s why comfort food is engineered around starch, fat, and salt in combinations that bypass your satiety signals. You don’t stop eating because you’re full. You stop because the bowl is empty.
I’m not saying this to make anyone feel guilty. I’m saying it because understanding the mechanism is the first step toward changing the relationship without ending it.
The morning-after test
Here’s the question I started asking: does this meal make me feel good tomorrow?
Not tonight. Tomorrow.
Because comfort food that only works for the hour you’re eating it isn’t comfort. It’s a distraction. Real comfort — the kind that actually serves you — should feel good in the moment and still feel good twelve hours later.
That became my filter. Not “is this healthy?” Not “is this clean?” Just: will I feel okay in the morning?
It eliminated some things. It kept others. And it made room for a third category — meals that feel just as warm and heavy and satisfying, but are built differently underneath.
Renegotiating the terms
You don’t have to break up with comfort food. You just have to renegotiate.
The mashed potatoes don’t need to go. But mixing them 50/50 with roasted cauliflower or parsnips gives you the same creamy, buttery texture with more fiber, which means your blood sugar doesn’t spike as hard and you don’t wake up in a fog. The comfort stays. The crash leaves.
The pasta can stay too. But a legume-based pasta holds sauce the same way and brings protein and fiber that white flour doesn’t. You keep the bowl, you keep the sauce, you keep the ritual of twirling and eating something warm. The foundation just got stronger.
The stew is already almost there. A slow-cooked one-pan stew with real broth, roasted vegetables, and warming spices — cinnamon, ginger, cumin — is comfort food that was never broken in the first place. It’s warm, it’s heavy, it’s grounding, and it’s built on ingredients your body actually knows what to do with.
A squeeze of lemon at the end of any heavy comfort dish changes the whole experience. The acid cuts through the fat, resets your palate between bites, and keeps the meal from sitting on you like a weight.
What comfort actually feels like
I still make mac and cheese sometimes. The real one. With the butter and the breadcrumbs. But it’s not the default anymore. It’s the occasion.
The default became something different — a big bowl of roasted vegetables over rice with tahini and lemon. A slow-simmered soup with beans and greens and enough garlic to fill the kitchen. A one-pan chicken with crispy skin and whatever was left in the fridge.
These meals don’t promise the same instant hit. There’s no dopamine firework at 9 PM. But at 7 AM the next morning, when I’m clear and light and actually want breakfast, I know the meal did its job.
That’s the difference between a situationship and something real.
The food that treats you well when you’re not looking — that’s comfort.
Follow the remix on IG @remixology