B-Side

I Have Crust Issues

Not making them. My issue is knowing which one to make — and for years that paralysis meant I avoided baking crusts almost entirely. I’d see a recipe that called for pâte à choux and close the tab. Too French. Too technical. Too many ways to fail.

The problem wasn’t skill. It was the belief that pastry had a steep entrance fee.

Then I actually made choux for the first time and stood in my kitchen feeling genuinely robbed. There’s no rolling. No chilling. No keep-the-butter-cold anxiety that plagues every pie crust tutorial on the internet. You cook it on the stovetop. You melt butter in water, dump in flour, stir it into a ball, then beat in eggs one at a time until the dough is smooth and glossy and pulls cleanly from the sides of the pan. That’s it. The whole technique. Something I’d avoided for a decade took twenty minutes and produced a dough that pipes into eclairs, cream puffs, and French crullers — the ridged, hollow, completely-air-filled rings that make people think you bought them from a bakery.

The dough didn’t care that I was nervous. It just needed fat, water, flour, and eggs in the right sequence.

That’s the thing I’ve learned about crust: each one has a logic, and once you understand the logic, the technique stops being intimidating and starts being inevitable.

Short crust

Short crust — the workhorse of savory baking — is called short because of its high fat-to-flour ratio. That fat ratio is what makes it crumbly and tender instead of chewy. You’re not building gluten. You’re coating the flour particles in fat so they can’t link up. Rub cold butter into flour until it looks like damp sand, add just enough water to bring it together, and you have a crust that can hold a quiche without getting soggy, a tart without shattering when you cut it. It forgives re-rolling in a way American pie crust doesn’t.

Pie crust

American pie crust — the flaky, layered, holiday-table standard — is different because you want distinct chunks of cold butter creating steam pockets when they hit the oven. That’s what makes the layers. You’re not rubbing the butter in, you’re leaving it in visible pieces. Keep it cold, work it fast, don’t overhandle it, and you get flaky layers that shatter at the fork. The reputation for difficulty comes from overworking it, which develops too much gluten and turns the crust tough. It’s not a temperamental dough. It’s just a cold one.

Three structures

Three crusts. Three logics. Choux when you want to produce something ethereal and impressive with no rolling involved. Short crust when you need a container sturdy enough to hold something wet. Flaky pie crust when you want visible layers and a shatter at the bite.

The decision paralysis disappears the moment you understand what each one is actually for. You’re not choosing a recipe. You’re choosing a structure.

Follow the remix on IG @remixology