B-Side

Bring Something

My friends Ken and Jason throw potlucks a few times a year, and by now it’s basically a formality when they ask what I’m bringing. We all know the answer. Dessert. They know I bake — I had a dessert restaurant, so it’s not exactly a stretch — and at this point it’s just my spot. Nobody has to assign it anymore.

What I like about it, though, isn’t just that I have a job. It’s that everyone does. The main course is always handled — Ken and Jason go big on that, every time, so that’s never a question mark. Everyone else fills in around it. Someone’s got salad. Someone’s got drinks. Someone’s doing appetizers. By the time everyone arrives, the table just sort of completes itself, and nobody had to coordinate much beyond what are you bringing.

That’s the part of potlucks I think people undersell. It’s not really about the food being free, or splitting up the work evenly. It’s that nobody is solely responsible for whether the meal is good. If Ken and Jason’s main course were the only thing on the table, that’s a lot of pressure on one dish, one couple, one effort. Instead, the meal is the sum of everyone’s small contribution, and if any one thing is just okay, it doesn’t sink anything — there’s a whole table of other things picking up the slack. That’s the actual trust part. Not “I trust you’ll bring something good,” exactly. More like: I trust that this table is going to work out, because enough people are showing up with something.

“Bring something” doesn’t mean cook something from scratch. It means show up with something that has a little thought in it. If you’re short on time, semi-homemade is completely fine — buy something and dress it up. Or go a step further. Get something special, somewhere people wouldn’t normally think to get it. If you happen to be in Julian a week before the potluck, that’s apple pie country — pick one up there, keep it in the fridge or the freezer, and bring it the day of. Nobody needs to know you got it a week ago. What they’ll see is a pie that didn’t come from down the street, and that’s the part that counts. You don’t have to be in the kitchen all afternoon. You just have to be a little creative about what bringing something looks like for you, this time, given what you’ve got.

The one move that actually breaks the whole system is showing up with something that’s obviously a last-minute grab — the grocery store run on the way over, sticker still on the lid, no thought given to it at all. It’s not that store-bought is the problem. It’s that “I ran in five minutes ago and grabbed whatever was closest to the door” sends a message, whether you mean it to or not. Somewhere in that house, someone spent real time on a main course they’re about to feed everyone. Bringing something that says I didn’t really think about this isn’t really participating in the same thing everyone else is. The fix isn’t expensive or hard — take the sticker off, put it on a plate instead of leaving it in the container. If you bought it, at least act like you chose it on purpose. That small amount of care is the difference between I brought something and I brought whatever.

What I like about the dessert role, honestly, is that it lets me bring the kind of effort that actually means something coming from me. I bake — I’ve always baked. So when I show up with dessert, that’s not me doing the minimum. That’s me doing the thing I’d want to be doing anyway, and it happens to be exactly what the table needed. Someone else’s version of that might be picking the perfect bottle of wine, or finding the one specific dip everyone always asks about, or driving out of their way to Julian a week early for a pie. The effort looks different depending on who you are. But it’s still effort, and it still says the same thing: I thought about this, and I wanted to bring something good. That’s what makes a potluck work. Not that everyone cooks. Just that everyone shows up having actually thought about what they’re putting on the table — because the table only works if everyone treats their piece of it like it matters.

Follow the remix on IG @remixology