The Setup
We fell for it. All of us.
Somewhere around 1985, my mom stopped buying butter. I don’t remember the exact moment, but I remember the replacement — a yellow tub of something called “spread” that lived in the door of the fridge. It tasted like nothing. It melted like plastic. And it had a list of ingredients longer than a permission slip.
We didn’t question it. Nobody did. The entire country had been told the same story: fat makes you fat. Fat clogs your arteries. Fat is the enemy. If you want to live longer, eat less of it.
So the food industry took the fat out of everything. And then they had a problem.
Food without fat tastes like cardboard.
The trade nobody agreed to
When you remove fat from food, the flavor goes with it. Fat is what carries aromatic compounds to your nose and across your tongue. Without it, garlic is just a sharp bite. Cheese is just salt. A salad dressing is just vinegar water.
To make low-fat food edible, manufacturers had to replace what they took out. They reached for two things: sugar and chemistry. High-fructose corn syrup. Stabilizers. Emulsifiers. Highly processed seed oils that could mimic the mouthfeel of fat without technically being fat.
We traded butter for spreads. Cream for whiteners. Whole milk for skim plus added sugar. The ingredient lists got longer. The food got worse. And we were told it was healthier.
It wasn’t. We didn’t get thinner. We got inflamed.
The part that makes me angry
Fat is satiety. It’s the thing that tells your brain you’ve had enough. It’s the stop button.
When you remove it, your body never gets the signal. You stay hungry. You eat more. You reach for snacks two hours after a meal because the meal didn’t finish the job it was supposed to do. Then you blame yourself for lacking willpower when the real problem is that your lunch was missing a macronutrient.
The low-fat era didn’t just change our grocery lists. It rewired our hunger. An entire generation learned to feel guilty about the one thing that would have kept them full.
The script was flipped
For decades we were told that saturated fats — butter, coconut oil, tallow, the fats humans cooked with for thousands of years — were killing us. Meanwhile, “heart-healthy” vegetable oils like soybean, canola, and corn oil were the heroes.
We now know it was the other way around.
Highly processed seed oils are unstable. They oxidize easily, especially at high heat. They promote inflammation — the kind that builds quietly over years. The fats our grandparents used? The ones the industry told us to throw away? Those are the ones that keep cell membranes flexible and hormones balanced.
The enemy was never the cow. It was the refinery.
What fat actually does in your kitchen
This is the part I wish I’d understood twenty years ago. Fat isn’t just about nutrition. It’s about physics.
Fat is a conductor. It’s the medium that moves flavor from the pan to your palate. When you sauté garlic in olive oil, the fat carries those aromatic compounds into the air and across your tongue in a way that water never could.
That’s why restaurant food tastes better. They’re not afraid of the butter.
And here’s the practical piece that changed how I cook: vitamins A, D, E, and K are fat-soluble. Your body can only absorb them in the presence of fat. If you’re eating a salad with fat-free dressing, the nutrients in those greens are passing right through you. You’re doing the work of eating well and getting almost none of the benefit.
A drizzle of good olive oil on that salad isn’t indulgence. It’s the delivery system.
The pantry swap
I’m not saying eat a stick of butter for breakfast. I’m saying stop apologizing for cooking with it.
The swap that matters most isn’t dramatic. It’s just paying attention to which fats are in your kitchen and where they came from. Extra virgin olive oil, avocado oil, grass-fed butter, coconut oil, ghee — these are stable, minimally processed fats that your body recognizes and knows what to do with.
The canola, the soybean, the corn oil, the “vegetable” oil that isn’t actually made from vegetables — those are the ones worth questioning. Not because fat is bad, but because processing is.
My mom eventually went back to butter. It took about thirty years. The spread is gone. The guilt is mostly gone too.
Some lies take a long time to undo.
Follow the remix on IG @remixology